14 Comments
User's avatar
Art King's avatar

Wow, wow. This essay is so powerful, so well written and so thought-provoking. I've been mulling it for days and passing it along to my piano loving friends. The 1790's technological revolution in Pianos and your story of Mr. Beethoven's response...then a segue to now and an invitation for your readers to connect the dots.

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it. I had fun writing it.

Expand full comment
Happy of Hippo's avatar

The opening chord of the Pathétique is a simple C minor chord in forte: Why should that have broken earlier pianos? It's dramatic, but not particularly loud to play (as many students must learn). I can see several things in the Pathétique that would have been difficult to impossible to pull of on earlier pianos: Like the sforzandos mentioned in the text, or indeed the "fp" dynamics starting with the very first chord. "Not breaking the piano" though...?

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

Maybe! I think it depends on the fortepiano.

Expand full comment
Thomas's avatar

Terrific piece, Dean. Thought-provoking and quite apropos of all the end-of-year appraisals-->New Year tidings we all tend to mull over this time of year.

This is the least important point in the story but that's great that M1 Air served you well for so long. I'm sure that, I'm guessing M4 Air/Pro will as well though : ))

All the best for 2025!

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

The m1 air is a goat laptop (and fwiw I replaced it with an m4 MacBook Pro, maxed out ram, nano texture display, but base chip since I wanted the extra battery life)

Expand full comment
David Valerio's avatar

Excellent piece!

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Alan's avatar

A very elegant analogy. Well done!

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Clyde Wright's avatar

Beautiful thoughts

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Nathan Lambert's avatar

related - on my reading list https://a.co/d/gNs8NkY, there’s a whole long follow up about evaluation for you

Expand full comment
Dean W. Ball's avatar

Thank you! Looks worthwhile, I gotta read.

I am glad that someone saw this post was intended to be evals-pilled :)

Expand full comment